Head-to-head

Male Excel vs Hims

Last updated: November 15, 2026

Male Excel has the higher Atlas Score (4.1 vs 3.1). Hims has the lower published starting price ($49/mo), though what each price includes differs; see the full reviews.

Independent comparison. We earn no commission from any provider listed. How we're funded · How we score providers

At a glance

Male ExcelHims
Atlas Score4.1/53.1/5
Lowest published price$142/mo$49/mo
Care modelTelehealthTelehealth
FormatsAt-home injection, Topical, OralAt-home injection, Oral
Coverage39 statesAll 50 states
Pricing details$99/mo membership ($79/mo paid annually) + medication from $62.50/mo (injections) or $90/mo (cream)Medication from $49/mo + $49 membership fee

How they score

Criterion (weight)Male ExcelHims
Medical safeguards 30%3.54.25
Pricing transparency 25%44
Reputation 20%50
Access & options 15%3.54
Customer terms 10%52

Each criterion is scored 0 to 5 from public information. How we score providers.

Which one fits you

Where Male Excel is stronger

  • Reputation: 5 vs 0. Trustpilot 4.5 (6,900+ reviews); BBB-accredited (A+); no regulatory actions found.
  • Customer terms: 5 vs 2. No long-term contract; 90-day guarantee published; HSA/FSA eligible.
  • More formats: offers topical, which Hims doesn't list.

Visit maleexcel.com →

Where Hims is stronger

  • Medical safeguards: 4.25 vs 3.5. Baseline labs before prescribing; membership includes two labs a year, provider review and check-ins; live visit only in some states.
  • Access & options: 4 vs 3.5. Most states; injection and oral; enclomiphene (Rx+) available.
  • Lower published starting price: $49/mo vs $142/mo. What each price includes differs, so compare the first-year totals in the reviews.
  • Wider coverage: markets itself in all 50 states; Male Excel lists 39.

Visit hims.com →

These points come from the same public information as the scores, and a half-point gap or more counts as a difference. The "Visit" links go to each provider's own site, and any link we're paid for is labeled. Which treatment is right for you is a decision for a licensed clinician.

Read the full reviews

This comparison summarizes public information and is not medical advice or an endorsement of either provider. Pricing and availability change; confirm details with the provider and talk to a licensed clinician before starting treatment.

Medical disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Testosterone replacement therapy requires a prescription and physician supervision. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before starting treatment.